Form I-9 Verification Support for Employers - NAIS New York

Services · Employer Compliance

Form I-9 Verification Support for Employers

Every U.S. employer must complete a Form I-9 for every person it hires, citizens included, and keep it on file. The form is only two pages, but the deadlines, document rules and reverification dates are where most problems start. We help you set up the process, check your existing forms and keep a calendar of what needs action.

Who this service is for

  • Small and mid-size New York employers with no written I-9 process.
  • Growing companies hiring remote staff across several states.
  • Employers with foreign national staff whose work authorization expires and needs reverification.
  • Businesses that want a self-audit before an inspection, an acquisition or a change of payroll provider.
  • E-Verify employers that want their I-9 and E-Verify records to match.

The rules in one table

ItemRule
Current formEdition 01/20/25, expires 05/31/2027. The 08/01/23 edition with the 05/31/2027 expiration is also accepted
Section 1Completed by the employee at the time of hire, no later than the first day of work
Section 2Completed by the employer within three business days of the first day of work
Jobs under three daysSection 2 must be done on the first day; a receipt is not acceptable
ReceiptsA receipt for a replacement of a lost, stolen or damaged document is valid for 90 days
ReverificationNo later than the date work authorization expires, using Supplement B
RehiresAn existing I-9 can be updated if the person is rehired within three years and still authorized
CopiesOptional, but if you copy for one employee, copy for all
Retention3 years after hire or 1 year after termination, whichever is later

Source: 8 CFR 274a.2 and the Form I-9 edition notice.

Not sure how many of your I-9s are on an expired edition? Book a free 20-minute consultation and we will tell you how to find out.

Book Free Consultation →

Where employers go wrong

  • Late Section 2. It's the most common error, especially for remote hires and short-term staff.
  • Over-documentation. Asking for a green card or a specific document instead of letting the employee choose.
  • Missed reverifications. An EAD expires and nobody notices. Since Oct 30, 2025, renewal EADs no longer carry an automatic extension, so more employees now have gaps.
  • Reverifying people who should not be reverified. U.S. citizens and green card holders are not reverified when a List B document or a green card expires.
  • Inconsistent copying, which can look like selective treatment.
  • Old forms kept too long or destroyed too early.

Remote hires: the alternative procedure vs. physical in-person inspection

Federal regulations under 8 CFR 274a.2 require employers to verify identity and work eligibility within three business days of hire. How you examine documents depends on whether your organization participates in E-Verify:

Verification StepDHS Alternative Procedure (E-Verify Enrolled)Physical Examination (Standard / Non-E-Verify)
Employer EligibilityMust be enrolled in E-Verify, in good standing, and enrolled at the specific hiring siteMandatory for all employers not enrolled in E-Verify, or at non-participating hiring sites
Document ExaminationReview electronic front and back copies upfront, then conduct a live interactive video call where employee presents physical documentsIn-person physical inspection of original documents; employer or designated authorized representative must physically handle documents
Form I-9 NotationCheck the “Alternative Procedure” checkbox in Section 2 (or Supplement B) on current Form I-9 editions (08/01/23 or 01/20/25, both expiring 05/31/2027)Leave the Alternative Procedure box unchecked; complete standard signature and physical address fields
Copy RetentionMandatory: must retain clear, legible copies of all front/back documents examined with the Form I-9Optional under federal law, but if copies are retained for one employee, they must be retained for all hires uniformly
Employee ChoiceIf a remote employee prefers in-person examination, the employer must accommodate physical inspection without penaltyStandard procedure; remote hires may use a company-designated authorized representative near their home

See the Federal Register notice on Alternative Procedure 1. For employers wishing to qualify for remote examination, our E-Verify page covers enrollment.

What we help with

  • Written I-9 procedure for each hiring site, including remote hires and authorized representatives.
  • Self-audit support. We review a sample or all of your I-9s against the rules above and list each issue with the correction method USCIS describes. You make and date the corrections. We never backdate or recreate forms.
  • Reverification calendar for every employee with an expiring EAD or other time-limited authorization.
  • Edition clean-up to move hiring packets and electronic systems to the current form.
  • Retention schedule so you know which forms you may destroy and which you must keep.
  • Coordination with visa filings, so H-1B, L-1, O-1 and other workers have I-9s that match their approval notices.

How we work

  1. Free consultation about your headcount, sites and current process.
  2. Written scope and flat fee before any work starts.
  3. Secure document review under your control, using only the records needed.
  4. Findings and corrections list, checked twice.
  5. Handover with a walkthrough for your HR team.

What's changed recently

  • July 31, 2026: the 08/01/23 edition of Form I-9 with a 07/31/2026 expiration date stopped being acceptable. Update paper packets and electronic systems to a form expiring 05/31/2027.
  • Oct 14, 2026: a final rule confirmed that EAD renewals filed on or after Oct 30, 2025 get no automatic extension. A renewal receipt alone no longer extends authorization for I-9 purposes in most categories, so reverify on the card's expiration date.
  • June 2025 onward: E-Verify employers get a Status Change Report flagging revoked EADs, which may require Supplement B reverification. See our E-Verify page.

Book a review before someone else does it

Call +1 (718) 973-9373, email info@newyorkareaimmigrationservices.com, or message us on WhatsApp (+1 510-770-8700 support desk).

Book your free 20-minute consultation. Manhattan office by appointment, or remote for employers anywhere in the U.S.

Book Free Consultation →
Disclaimer: We are not attorneys in the U.S. Kindly do not depend upon us for legal advice. Our scope of services is limited to documentation for immigration petitions.

FAQs

Frequently Asked Questions

The current edition is dated 01/20/25 and expires 05/31/2027. The 08/01/23 edition with a 05/31/2027 expiration is also accepted. The 08/01/23 version marked to expire 07/31/2026 stopped being valid after that date.

Yes. Every employee hired after November 6, 1986 needs a Form I-9, regardless of citizenship. Independent contractors are not your employees for I-9 purposes, but how you classify a worker matters.

No. The employee chooses from the Lists of Acceptable Documents. You may reject a document only if it does not reasonably appear genuine or relate to the person. Demanding particular documents can be discrimination.

Three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later. Keep them for current employees for as long as they work for you.

Only if you are an E-Verify employer in good standing at that hiring site and follow the DHS alternative procedure: review copies, hold a live video call, tick the box on the form and keep the copies. Otherwise documents must be examined in person, which an authorized representative can do for you.

No. We are a documentation service. We help you build and review your I-9 records. If an audit raises questions about penalties or liability, you should speak to employment or immigration counsel.

Client Reviews

Verified Google Reviews

Feedback from individuals, families and employers who worked with NAIS on their U.S. immigration documentation.

Ready to review your documentation?

Book a free 20-minute consultation with our Manhattan team. We'll outline the documents involved and quote a flat fee in writing.